Yet in many workers’ compensation programs, an investigation can’t start until someone requests it, someone else approves it, and a vendor is scheduled. By the time the investigation begins, much of its value is gone. The fix is making the decision before the claim ever arrives.
Why Case-by-Case Approval Creates Delay
When investigations require individual approval, the adjuster has to recognize the need, explain it, and wait for a response. With a heavy caseload, that request competes with dozens of other priorities.
Meanwhile, the employer may assume the claims administrator will investigate automatically. The claims administrator may assume the employer will ask if they want one. Both sides are waiting for the other. Nothing happens.
Imagine an unwitnessed back injury reported a week after it occurred. The adjuster flags it and emails the employer for approval. The approver is traveling. Approval arrives a few days later, and then the vendor needs time to schedule. By the time anyone speaks with coworkers, their memories have blurred together. The chance to establish clear facts has narrowed.
Click Link to Access Free PDF Download
“The 6-Step Process To Determine Workers’ Comp Injury Causation”
No one did anything wrong. The process simply wasn’t designed for speed. Account handling instructions can remove that gap by answering one question in advance: in which situations is investigation already authorized?
Decide the Triggers in Advance
A pre-authorized investigation instruction might read:
“The adjuster is authorized to order an investigation of up to a defined number of days, without further approval, when any of the following occur.”
The triggers should be specific and observable. Common examples include:
- The injury was reported late.
- There were no witnesses.
- The employee’s account and the supervisor’s account conflict.
- A manager raises a specific, documented concern.
- The described mechanism of injury doesn’t match the job duties involved.
The exact list will differ by organization. What matters is that the adjuster doesn’t have to guess.Some employers choose a broader approach and authorize investigation on every lost-time claim. Others keep the list narrow to control cost. Either approach can be reasonable. The important thing is making a deliberate decision instead of leaving it to chance.
Write the Instruction Completely
A trigger tells the adjuster when to act. A complete instruction also tells them how.
Consider including:
- Scope: what the investigation should cover, such as scene review, witness statements, or prior claim history where permitted
- Limit: the number of days or dollar amount pre-authorized before additional approval is needed
- Vendor: whether a specific investigation company must be used or may be used
- Start time: how quickly the investigation should begin after the trigger occurs
- Delivery: when the report is due and who receives it
These details keep pre-authorization from becoming open-ended. They also give the adjuster confidence to act immediately, because the boundaries are already set.
Support the Investigator
Pre-authorization only works if the investigator can move quickly once assigned.
The employer plays a direct role here. Investigators often need:
- Supervisor contact information
- Witness names
- Access to the work area
- Job descriptions
- Schedules or time records
Designate one person to coordinate these requests. An investigator who waits days for a return call loses the same ground the pre-authorization was meant to protect.
Investigation Is Fact-Finding, Not Accusation
An investigation clarifies what happened. It shouldn’t suggest that the employer doubts the employee. Most claims are legitimate. When employees sense their employer is treating them with suspicion, trust erodes quickly, and the claim often becomes harder to resolve.
That’s one more reason to define triggers in advance. When investigations follow consistent criteria, they’re less likely to feel personal or arbitrary. The same facts lead to the same response, regardless of who was injured. Investigation practices, especially surveillance, are subject to rules that vary by jurisdiction. Confirm your approach with your claims administrator and counsel.
Then Read the Report
Pre-authorizing an investigation solves half the problem. The other half happens after the report is delivered. Too often, investigation reports are ordered, completed, paid for, and filed without anyone reviewing them carefully.
A report can tell you several things:
- Whether it confirms the employee’s account
- Whether it raises legitimate questions about compensability
- Whether it reveals a safety hazard or process breakdown
- Whether any witnesses need follow-up
None of that helps if no one reads it. If a report won’t be read, the investigation becomes an expense rather than a tool.
Your account instructions should define what happens after delivery:
- Who receives the report
- How quickly it must be reviewed
- Who decides the next step based on the findings
- Where that decision is documented
This is the same discipline that makes any instruction work: a clear decision, a trigger, a timeline, and a named person responsible.
Close the Loop in Your Reviews
Investigations should also come up in claim reviews. Look back periodically at the investigations that were ordered and ask:
- Did the triggers identify the right claims?
- Did investigations start quickly enough to be useful?
- Were findings acted on?
The answers help you refine your instructions and spend investigation dollars where they produce real value.
Final Thoughts
Investigations are most valuable when they happen early and when their findings are used. Deciding the triggers in advance handles the first part. Assigning responsibility for reading and acting on the report handles the second.
Together, they turn investigation from an occasional reaction into a dependable part of your claims management system.
Contact: mstack@reduceyourworkerscomp.com.
Workers’ Comp Roundup Blog: http://blog.reduceyourworkerscomp.com/
Injury Management Results (IMR) Software: https://imrsoftware.com/
©2025 Amaxx LLC. All rights reserved under International Copyright Law.
Do not use this information without independent verification. All state laws vary. You should consult with your insurance broker, attorney, or qualified professional.
