The Spaghetti Tower Study: Kindergarteners Can Teach Us About Reducing Workers' Comp Costs

In a groundbreaking group dynamics exercise, Peter Skillman, an engineer, conducted a fascinating study across several universities, including Stanford, University of California, and Tokyo University. The challenge was simple yet revealing: participants had to build the tallest tower possible using 20 pieces of uncooked spaghetti, one yard of transparent tape, one yard of string, and a single marshmallow, which had to sit on top of the tower.

Skillman assembled diverse groups, including CEOs, attorneys, business students, and kindergartners, to observe their interactions and compare results. The study’s findings are not only surprising but also hold profound lessons about teamwork, communication, and the ingredients for a positive organizational culture. These lessons also extend to reducing workers’ compensation costs through better collaboration and proactive problem-solving.

Business Students vs. Kindergartners: A Tale of Unexpected Success

One of the most striking comparisons in the study was between business students from elite universities and kindergartners. Intuitively, one might assume that the business students, with their education and analytical skills, would excel. However, the results told a different story:

Average height of towers built by business students: 10 inches
Average height of towers built by kindergartners: 26 inches

The kindergartners outperformed the business students by over 2.5 times. Why? The key lies in how the groups approached the task. While business students spent significant time strategizing, dividing roles, and negotiating hierarchy, kindergartners dove straight into action, experimenting and adapting as they went. Their iterative process and willingness to collaborate without ego proved far more effective than the calculated but rigid approach of the business students.

This outcome highlights an essential principle: success in group dynamics often hinges on the ability to collaborate openly, experiment freely, and prioritize shared goals over individual roles. In the context of workers’ compensation, fostering a similar collaborative environment can lead to earlier injury reporting, effective hazard identification, and creative solutions for return-to-work programs, ultimately reducing costs.

Lessons for Organizations: Building a Positive Culture to Reduce Workers’ Comp Costs

Understanding why kindergartners succeeded offers valuable insights for organizations aiming to foster a positive and productive culture. These lessons extend to the implementation of autonomy and building safety—two critical components of a thriving workplace that directly impact workers’ compensation outcomes.

Autonomy and Building Safety: A Framework for Action

Creating an environment where employees feel safe to share ideas and take initiative requires intentional effort. Daniel Pink, in his book Drive, outlines a three-part framework to cultivate autonomy:

Ask the Right Questions: Shift the focus from limitations (“What can’t I do?”) to opportunities (“What can I do?”). Encourage individuals to identify small, actionable steps within their sphere of influence to make a positive impact.
Don’t Ask for Permission—Act: Empower employees to implement minor changes without waiting for management approval. Prematurely seeking permission can stifle creativity and delay progress.
Lead with Results: Demonstrate the value of new ideas by presenting outcomes. For instance, “I noticed a recurring issue causing inefficiencies, so I made this change, and here are the results.” This approach makes it easier for management to support and scale successful initiatives.

Additional Considerations for Fostering Autonomy and Safety

Ensure Everyone Has a Voice: Teams work more effectively when all members feel free to contribute ideas. In a workers’ compensation context, this openness encourages employees to report injuries promptly, identify hazards, and suggest transitional-duty opportunities. Early reporting and hazard mitigation are key to preventing costly claims and minimizing downtime.
Hire the Right People: Autonomy thrives on trust. Using tools like integrity tests during hiring can help identify candidates who align with an organization’s values and are less likely to engage in counterproductive behaviors. Trustworthy employees are more likely to follow safety protocols and report injuries or hazards without fear.
Communicate Expectations Clearly: Transparency fosters collaboration. For example, proactively involving injured workers in identifying light-duty roles signals their value to the organization and promotes faster recovery. Clear communication also reduces misunderstandings and potential disputes, lowering the likelihood of prolonged claims.

Practical Applications: Small Steps to Reduce Workers’ Comp Costs

Many organizations have successfully implemented autonomy and safety practices through small-scale pilot programs. For example, companies like Google use “20% time,” allowing employees to dedicate a portion of their workweek to self-initiated projects. This approach has led to groundbreaking innovations, such as Gmail, and demonstrates the power of empowering employees to pursue their passions.

Even minor steps can signal a shift away from micromanagement. Encouraging employees to experiment with solutions, share ideas, and collaborate can gradually transform workplace culture. For example, allowing workers to propose and test ideas for transitional-duty jobs following an injury fosters both autonomy and mastery.

In the workers’ compensation realm, these small steps can have tangible impacts:

Earlier Injury Reporting: When employees feel safe to report injuries without fear of retribution, claims can be addressed promptly, reducing medical costs and litigation risks.
Hazard Identification: Empowered employees are more likely to spot and address potential safety issues before they result in injuries.
Effective Return-to-Work Programs: Collaboration between employees and management to create meaningful transitional-duty roles can expedite recovery and minimize lost productivity.

Building a Collaborative Future

The Spaghetti Tower Study underscores the value of collaboration, experimentation, and an ego-free approach to problem-solving. Kindergartners succeeded not because they were more knowledgeable but because they instinctively prioritized teamwork and adaptability. Organizations can learn from this by fostering a culture that values safety, autonomy, and open communication.

By taking small, actionable steps—from empowering employees to lead with results to ensuring everyone’s voice is heard—companies can create an environment where innovation and collaboration thrive. The result? A stronger, more resilient culture where both individuals and teams reach new heights—much like the kindergartners’ spaghetti towers. And in the context of workers’ compensation, these cultural improvements translate into reduced costs, healthier employees, and a safer workplace.

Michael Stack, CEO of Amaxx LLC, is an expert in workers’ compensation cost containment systems and provides education, training, and consulting to help employers reduce their workers’ compensation costs by 20% to 50%. He is co-author of the #1 selling comprehensive training guide “Your Ultimate Guide to Mastering Workers’ Comp Costs: Reduce Costs 20% to 50%.” Stack is the creator of Injury Management Results (IMR) software and founder of Amaxx Workers’ Comp Training Center. WC Mastery Training teaching injury management best practices such as return to work, communication, claims best practices, medical management, and working with vendors. IMR software simplifies the implementation of these best practices for employers and ties results to a Critical Metrics Dashboard.

Contact: [email protected].

Workers’ Comp Roundup Blog: http://blog.reduceyourworkerscomp.com/

Injury Management Results (IMR) Software: https://imrsoftware.com/

Do not use this information without independent verification. All state laws vary. You should consult with your insurance broker, attorney, or qualified professional.