• Menu
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to secondary navigation
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

Before Header

  • About
  • Contact
  • Privacy
 
ARCADIA: Stronger Settlement Partnerships. Innovative Solutions.

Amaxx Workers Comp Blog

Reduce Workers Compensation Costs By 20-50%

Header Right

  • Home
    • Training Center
  • Search
    • Free Resources & Solutions
    • Subscribe to Free Newsletter
    • Create Free Training Center Account
    • Enroll in On-Demand Courses
    • Activate WC Mastery Membership
    • Request Strategic Coaching Session
    • Buy WC Guidebooks
  • Membership
    • Insider (free account)
    • WC Mastery
    • Teams & Managers Mastery
    • Training Partners
  • Products
    • On-Demand Courses
    • Specialty Courses
    • Certifications & Mastery Courses
    • Ultimate Guidebooks
    • Coaching
  • Blog
    • Video Blogs
    • COVID-19 / Coronavirus Pandemic
  • Login

Mobile Menu

  • Home
    • Training Center
  • Search
    • Free Resources & Solutions
    • Subscribe to Free Newsletter
    • Create Free Training Center Account
    • Enroll in On-Demand Courses
    • Activate WC Mastery Membership
    • Request Strategic Coaching Session
    • Buy WC Guidebooks
  • Membership
    • Insider (free account)
    • WC Mastery
    • Teams & Managers Mastery
    • Training Partners
  • Products
    • On-Demand Courses
    • Specialty Courses
    • Certifications & Mastery Courses
    • Ultimate Guidebooks
    • Coaching
  • Blog
    • Video Blogs
    • COVID-19 / Coronavirus Pandemic
  • Login
  • About
  • Contact
  • Privacy
You are here: Home / Claim Management / Legal Doctrines / The Prohibited Acts Doctrine: Do Not Pass GO; Do Not Collect $200

The Prohibited Acts Doctrine: Do Not Pass GO; Do Not Collect $200

December 11, 2014 By //  by Michael B. Stack Leave a Comment

monopoly.images

 

The Prohibited Acts Doctrine is used in workers’ compensation cases as a primary liability defense. While this defense is something every claims management team should explore in workplace injuries, it is often difficult to employ successfully.

A Hypothetical

Consider the case of a truck driver. As part of the hiring process, the employee underwent a three-day orientation and received a copy of the employer’s policy manual. The manual included a number of statements concerning employee conduct, which included a prohibition of the “possession or consumption of alcoholic beverage while on company property, using company equipment, or traveling for work.”

Shortly after employment begins, the employee stopped in central Kentucky for a two-day layover. On the first full day of his layover, the employee wanted to watch the big basketball game and was told by an attendant at the truck stop he was staying that there was a bar about one mile away that had the game on the television. That afternoon he walked to the bar to watch the game and consumed “a few alcoholic drinks.”

Click Link to Access Free PDF Download

“Avoid the 3 Primary Reasons Injured Workers’ Hire Attorneys”

While walking back to the truck stop, a car with bright lights approached the employee, slowed to a crawl, and then accelerated causing him to jump back. The employee fell off the road into a ditch hitting the base of his spine. A workers’ compensation action was initiated related to this incident and primary liability was denied based on the Prohibited Acts Doctrine.

Sounds like a clear-cut case for the defense, right?

Application of the Prohibited Acts Doctrine

As a general rule, an employer/insurer can successfully use the Prohibited Acts Doctrine “where an employer expressly prohibits the doing of a certain specific act, the disregard of which is not reasonably foreseeable to the employer, a violation thereof takes the employee outside the scope of his employment and injuries resulting therefrom are not compensable even though the act might be considered to be in furtherance of the employer’s business.”[1] Whether the employee’s performance of a prohibited act takes the employee outside the sphere of the employment depends, in part, on the nature of the act or conduct, which is prohibited. Not every safety rule limits the scope of employment. The less hazardous the conduct prohibited by the safety rule, the more likely the rule proscribes conduct within the scope of employment. The more routine or minor the prohibited conduct, the more foreseeable it is an employee will violate the rule.[2]

Based upon the general application of the Doctrine, an employer and insurer asserting this defense in the above hypothetical would likely not prevail. Even if consuming alcohol is prohibited, courts will often look to other factors such as the nature of one’s employment, rules considering traveling employees and other factors such as the surface or condition that play a role in the subsequent injury.

FREE DOWNLOAD: ” Avoid the 3 Primary Reasons Injured Workers’ Hire Attorneys “

Tips to Successfully Asserting a Defense

Cases involving a Prohibited Acts Doctrine are complex, fact dependent and vary in each jurisdiction. Employees are also given some latitude by the courts when the defense is asserted. It is important to remember the following considerations associated with the defense:

  1. Each case should be analyzed on its own merits and fact. Other factors that make it a difficult defense to assert successfully include obtaining information and testimony from eyewitnesses and specific documentation or prohibitions by an employer. Just because something is prohibited does not mean one will be successful when asserting the defense.
  2. Practitioners should also note that the prohibited act must also be causally connected to the injury. An injured worker will likely succeed in their claim if the prohibited act plays little to no role in the injury.
  3. Cases involving a prohibited acts defense may also include other defenses such as possible intoxication or the foreseeable activities of traveling employees.

[1] Bartley v. C-H Riding Stables, Inc., 206 N.W.2d 660, 663, 26 W.C.D. 675, 678-80 (Minn. 1973)

[2] Otto v. Midwest of Cannon Falls, 59 W.C.D. 25, 35 (W.C.C.A. 1999)

Author Michael Stack, Principal of Amaxx Risk Solutions, Inc. He is an expert in employer communication systems and helps employers reduce their workers comp costs by 20% to 50%. He resides in the Boston area and works as a Qualified Loss Management Program provider working with high experience modification factor companies in the Massachusetts State Risk Pool. As the senior editor of Amaxx’s publishing division, Michael is on the cutting edge of innovation and thought leadership in workers compensation cost containment. http://reduceyourworkerscomp.com/about/. Contact: mstack@reduceyourworkerscomp.com.

©2014 Amaxx Risk Solutions, Inc. All rights reserved under International Copyright Law.

SALES TO PAY FOR ACCIDENTS CALCULATOR: http://reduceyourworkerscomp.com/sales-to-pay-for-accidents-calculator/

MODIFIED DUTY CALCULATOR: http://reduceyourworkerscomp.com/transitional-duty-cost-calculators/

WC GROUP: http://www.linkedin.com/groups?homeNewMember=&gid=1922050/

SUBSCRIBE: Workers Comp Resource Center Newsletter

Do not use this information without independent verification. All state laws vary. You should consult with your insurance broker, attorney, or qualified professional.

FREE DOWNLOAD: ” Avoid the 3 Primary Reasons Injured Workers’ Hire Attorneys “

Filed Under: Legal Doctrines

Related Articles

Cocaine Bear and the Work Comp Intoxication Defense

Cocaine Bear and the Work Comp Intoxication Defense

Is an Injured Employee’s Transitional Duty Work at a Charity Tax Deductible?

Is an Injured Employee’s Transitional Duty Work at a Charity Tax Deductible?

OJ Simpson, Level Of Certainty and Workers’ Comp Injury Causation

OJ Simpson, Level Of Certainty and Workers’ Comp Injury Causation

Hire Lawyers, Not Law Firms to Defend Workers’ Comp Claims

Hire Lawyers, Not Law Firms to Defend Workers’ Comp Claims

Using Defense Attorneys to Defend Work Comp Cases

Using Defense Attorneys to Defend Work Comp Cases

Workers’ Comp Injuries At Home

Workers’ Comp Injuries At Home

3 Common Defenses Against Illegitimate Workers’ Comp Claims

3 Common Defenses Against Illegitimate Workers’ Comp Claims

Your Adjuster Has a Critical Role in Legal Defense Management

Your Adjuster Has a Critical Role in Legal Defense Management

Work Comp Compensability – Understanding Jurisdictional Questions

Work Comp Compensability – Understanding Jurisdictional Questions

3 Steps to Reduce Your Workers’ Comp Litigation Rate

3 Steps to Reduce Your Workers’ Comp Litigation Rate

Personal Comfort Doctrine Does Not Provide Comfort In Workers’ Comp

Personal Comfort Doctrine Does Not Provide Comfort In Workers’ Comp

Ensure Case Integrity With Unrepresented Work Comp Claimant

Ensure Case Integrity With Unrepresented Work Comp Claimant

Train to Succeed

BECOME CERTIFIED IN WORKERS’ COMPENSATION

Proven Course Catalog & WC Toolbox Give You The Power To Achieve Lower Costs and Better Injured Worker Outcomes

VISIT WORKERS' COMP TRAINING CENTER

Free Download

How To Avoid, Manage, And Win Workers' Comp Claim Litigation - FREE Download Click Here Now!

Previous Post: « New Zealand Employer Hit with $37K Fine
Next Post: EEOC Speaks Out on Workers Compensation ADA Obligations »

Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Primary Sidebar

FREE DOWNLOAD

How To Avoid, Manage, And Win Workers' Comp Claim Litigation - FREE Download Click Here Now!

Our Sponsors

ARCADIA - Enhancing Settlement Outcomes

The Structured Settlements Company
 

Catastrophic and Risk Solutions, Case Management Solutions, and Specialty Networks
 

Post-Settlement Administration
 

Medcor

Injury Triage, Onsite Clinics

Read Our Award-Winning Blog

Blog Categories

Search Our Archive

Subscribe to Our FREE Newsletter

Return-to-Work Essentials

Footer

Search Our Archive

Search our continually growing archive of over 2500 articles about Workers' Comp issues.

Quiclinks

  • Calculators
  • Terms & Abbreviations
  • Glossary of WC Premium Terms
  • WC Resources
  • Best Practices
  • Industries
  • Return-to-Work Essentials

RSS Recent Blog Posts

  • 11 Tips for Taking an Effective Recorded Statement in Workers’ Compensation Claims
  • 10 Best Practices for the Workers Compensation Claim Handler
  • Properly Handling Mental Claims in Workers’ Compensation
SUBSCRIBE TO OUR FEE NEWSLETTER
Let Us Help You Stomp Down the High Cost of Workers' Comp!
Top of Page ↑
  • Home
  • Training Center
  • Search
  • Membership
  • Products
  • Blog
  • About
  • Contact
  • Subscribe
  • Login
Copyright © 2023 Amaxx, LLC. All Rights Reserved. · Privacy Policy / Legal Notice