• Menu
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to secondary navigation
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

Before Header

  • Search
  • About
  • Contact
  • Privacy
 
CHOOSE BROADSPIRE

Amaxx Workers Comp Blog

Reduce Workers Compensation Costs By 20-50%

Header Right

  • Home
    • Training Center
  • Get Started
    • Newcomers Class for WC Professionals
    • Subscribe to Free Newsletter
    • Free Training Center Account
    • Return to Work Resources
    • WC Claims Mgmt. Resources
    • Insurance Advisor Resources
  • Membership
    • Insider (free account)
    • WC Mastery
    • Teams & Managers Mastery
    • Training Partners
  • Products
    • On-Demand Courses
    • Specialty Courses
    • Certifications & Mastery Courses
    • Ultimate Guidebooks
  • Blog
    • Video Blogs
    • COVID-19 / Coronavirus Pandemic
  • Login

Mobile Menu

Choose Broadspire

CHOOSE BROADSPIREBroadspire Delivers Meaningful Results to Our Clients and Their Claimants
  • Home
    • Training Center
  • Get Started
    • Newcomers Class for WC Professionals
    • Subscribe to Free Newsletter
    • Free Training Center Account
    • Return to Work Resources
    • WC Claims Mgmt. Resources
    • Insurance Advisor Resources
  • Membership
    • Insider (free account)
    • WC Mastery
    • Teams & Managers Mastery
    • Training Partners
  • Products
    • On-Demand Courses
    • Specialty Courses
    • Certifications & Mastery Courses
    • Ultimate Guidebooks
  • Blog
    • Video Blogs
    • COVID-19 / Coronavirus Pandemic
  • Login
  • Search
  • About
  • Contact
  • Privacy
You are here: Home / Claim Management / To Replace or Not Replace that Shoulder

To Replace or Not Replace that Shoulder

July 19, 2012 By //  by Rebecca Shafer, J.D. Leave a Comment

At one time or another as an employer you are going to experience work comp injuries.  Some of these injuries are minor in nature, while some can be severe and life-changing. 

Joint Replacement More Common – Very Difficult Claims

The nature of joint replacement can rear its ugly head from time to time.  In the past, joint replacement surgery was only thought to have occurred in older employees, with a lifetime of cumulative injury to the specific joint, be it the knee, hip, shoulder, or ankle.  But now Carriers are starting to see knee and shoulder replacement surgeries in younger to middle-aged employees.  This type of injury and subsequent surgery can lead to very difficult claims in the field of workers compensation. [Wcx]

In the past, Carriers were quick to deny surgeries such as these on the basis of the need for the surgery not being totally occupational in nature.  Once this replacement surgery is performed, it is seldom a “one-time” procedure.  The life span of prosthetic joints was said to be short, with it being a positive outcome if the prosthesis would last 3-5-7 years.

Click Link to Access Free PDF Download

“How Do I Get My Adjusters To Follow My Account Handling Instructions?”

Advances Made in Surgery, Much Homework Still Needs to be Done

Recently over the course of the last handful of years several advancements have been made in the field of joint replacements, and several surgeons are getting quicker to recommend joint replacement surgery as a way to resolve ongoing pain and the need for opiate medication on a long-term basis.  Joint replacement has led to a better quality of life, and an increase in overall functionality in the right candidate.  But in the world of work comp, carriers are still very slow to accept these procedures without a lot of homework done beforehand. Let’s look at some of the pros and cons of these types of procedures:

 PROS – Less Pain Meds, Decreased Long-Term Treatment 

The first positive for getting joint replacement surgery is the decreased need for ongoing pain medication.  Expensive, and often addictive in nature, surgeons will point out that the prosthesis can lead to be a functional way of life without the need of strong pain-relievers, automatically positively impacting the overall expense of the work comp claim.  Decreased needs for physical therapy, diagnostic testing such as MRIs and EMGs, and decreased loss of work time after rehabilitation are all positive indicators that can mean less wasted claim dollars.

The technology involved in the actual lifespan of the prosthesis has improved as well over the last 10-20 years.  In the past, prosthetics were often drowned out in negativity, with insurers quick to point out that the lifespan is really an unknown.  In certain cases, the replacement could last 15 years whereas in others it could fail right out of the starting gate.  The price tag on these surgeries can hover well over $100,000 after all of the surgeries, diagnostics, physical therapy, medications, and so on, and that doesn’t include lost wages away from work and decreased productivity once the employee returns to gainful employment.  However, all of these are past stereotypes and research has shown more positive outcomes.  It varies from patient to patient, but, most injured workers have decreased pain levels, which can be the most important factor.

Need Proper Evaluation to Determine if Surgery is Correct Answer

There may be no model for the perfect joint replacement candidate because everyone’s body varies.  Age, arthritis, functionality,pain tolerance, patience, activity level, job tasks, employer flexibility, job experience, and other pre-existing conditions need to be taken into careful account before a procedure like this is even considered.  I have seen some cases where the doctor will start off with a rotator cuff tear repair, only to end up recommending a total or partial shoulder replacement within 2-3 months post-surgery.  This may be quick to jump the gun considering the extent of the injury, however, the adjuster has to consider if the injured worker will fail a number of surgeries before finally considering joint replacement.

 CONS – Fear of the Unknown, Will the Surgery Work? 

I believe that the strongest con involved in these procedures is the factor of the unknown.  Carriers like to know facts, and have statistically-guaranteed outcomes.  Unfortunately with joint replacement procedures there is not a guarantee.  You can send the claimant for a few IMEs with different surgeons and get a feel for what they think will happen, but until that patient goes under the knife all bets are off. These claims and injuries have to be evaluated on a case-by-case basis.  Your risk drivers will help to determine if authorizing these procedures will lead to a best outcome. 

The biggest unknown of them all is the actual claimant.  Psychologically, surgeries are not a magic bullet.  There can be months of pain and rehab ahead, and your injured worker may not be the most patient person in the world.  In my experience dealing with these procedures post-op, the most common complaint is they want to know when they will be better and able to function like they did prior to the injury.  The truth is, some people will never be the same.  They may never be able to pick up their kids or grandkids and toss them in the air as they did before.  They may not be able to lift 30lbs over chest level or they may never be able to squat down and garden in their front yard pain-free as they once did.  And this fear of the unknown can stop many people from even wanting to go through with a procedure with such unknown results.

Carriers Often Settle Early to Ensure End to Claim

The reality is that with these invasive surgeries is nobody knows the outcome. This can scare off adjusters from authorization and steer the claim into litigation for settlement, which could be just as costly.  Carriers calculate if the claim were to settle, they know the outcome and the associated costs.  If a claim such as this were to settle for $250,000 at least the Carrier can pay that, and be done with it.  Whereas if the carrier sinks $100,000+ into this procedure, who knows if this person will need another surgery in 5 or 7 years, and maybe that surgery is the one that will fail even worse than the first one.

FREE DOWNLOAD: “How Do I Get My Adjusters To Follow My Account Handling Instructions?”

Carriers fear unknown future costs, and fear even more the potential for a claim to have to be re-opened with a higher expense in the future. Settlement leads to the end of the claim and guarantees that it is over. Your claimant receives a check, and you close the file knowing it cannot be reopen years down the road. Carriers have to hedge risk which can cost them greatly upfront in Court, but they get comfort knowing the claim is over.  This isn’t to say that the carrier doesn’t care; after all, the claimant has to be on board with settlement for it to go forward.  This maybe the best way for all parties to move forward with each satisfied with the outcome.  Of course, each case will vary greatly from one to another, which is the hardest part involving claim of this nature. [Wcx]

 Summary 

If a claimant has a recommendation for joint replacement surgery, your carrier has to do their homework.  Whether is it involving the knee, shoulder, hip, or ankle, I would be surprised if any carrier or adjuster accepted the need for a joint replacement surgery without taking the time to gather years’ worth of past medical records, get a few IMEs, and evaluate the case very carefully.  These procedures affect the claimant in one way or another, either positively or negatively.  It is only after the procedure that all parties know if it is worth it in the end or not.

Author Rebecca Shafer, JD, President of Amaxx Risk Solutions, Inc. is a national expert in the field of workers compensation. She is a writer, speaker, and publisher. Her expertise is working with employers to reduce workers compensation costs, and her clients include airlines, healthcare, printing/publishing, pharmaceuticals, retail, hospitality, and manufacturing. She is the author of the #1 selling book on cost containment, Workers Compensation Management Program: Reduce Costs 20% to 50%. Contact: RShafer@ReduceYourWorkersComp.com.

Editor Michael B. Stack, CPA, Director of Operations, Amaxx Risk Solutions, Inc. is an expert in employer communication systems and part of the Amaxx team helping companies reduce their workers compensation costs by 20% to 50%. He is a writer, speaker, and website publisher.  www.reduceyourworkerscomp.com.  Contact:  mstack@reduceyourworkerscomp.com.

WORKERS COMP MANAGEMENT MANUAL:  www.WCManual.com

Do not use this information without independent verification. All state laws vary. You should consult with your insurance broker or agent about workers comp issues.

 

©2012 Amaxx Risk Solutions, Inc. All rights reserved under International Copyright Law. If you would like permission to reprint this material, contact us at: Info@ReduceYourWorkersComp.com.

FREE DOWNLOAD: “How Do I Get My Adjusters To Follow My Account Handling Instructions?”

Filed Under: Claim Management Tagged With: Claims Handling, Claims Resolution and Settlement, Closing a Claims Medical Payments, Knee Replacement, Settling WC Claims

Related Articles

Selecting the Right Service Providers to Reduce Workers’ Comp Costs

Selecting the Right Service Providers to Reduce Workers’ Comp Costs

Part 3: What to Do AFTER a Workers’ Comp Claim Audit

Part 3: What to Do AFTER a Workers’ Comp Claim Audit

Part 2: Select the Right Claims for a Workers’ Comp Claim Audit

Part 2: Select the Right Claims for a Workers’ Comp Claim Audit

Part 1: Stop Wasting Time Doing Workers’ Comp Claim Audits

Part 1: Stop Wasting Time Doing Workers’ Comp Claim Audits
workers' comp Investigation

Best in Class Claims Investigation

Best in Class Claims Investigation

Review Your Claim Management Systems

Review Your Claim Management Systems

Why Every Employer Should Request Their Account Handling Instructions

Why Every Employer Should Request Their Account Handling Instructions

16 Points you MUST include in your Account Handling Instructions

16 Points you MUST include in your Account Handling Instructions

20 Unfair Claim Practices For Your Adjuster To Avoid

20 Unfair Claim Practices For Your Adjuster To Avoid

Complete A Better Accident Investigation

Complete A Better Accident Investigation

One Critical Step To Start Any Injured Worker Investigation

One Critical Step To Start Any Injured Worker Investigation

One Tip To Make Claims Reviews an Effective Use of Time

One Tip To Make Claims Reviews an Effective Use of Time

Free Download

How Do I Get My Adjusters To Follow My Account Handling Instructions? - FREE Download Click Here Now!

Train to Succeed

BECOME CERTIFIED IN WORKERS’ COMPENSATION

Proven Course Catalog & WC Toolbox Give You The Power To Achieve Lower Costs and Better Injured Worker Outcomes

VISIT WORKERS' COMP TRAINING CENTER

Previous Post: « Top 10 Ways to Control Your Workers Comp Costs
Next Post: Changes to FECA Reflected at this Year’s Federal Workers’ Compensation Conference »

Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Primary Sidebar

FREE DOWNLOAD

How Do I Get My Adjusters To Follow My Account Handling Instructions? - FREE Download Click Here Now!

Our Sponsors

Broadspire

Workers’ Comp 3rd-Party Administrator
 

Catastrophic Care Management, Complex Care, and Specialty Networks
 

Ametros

Post-Settlement Administration
 

Medcor

Injury Triage, Onsite Clinics

Read Our Award-Winning Blog

Blog Categories

Search Our Archive

Subscribe to Our FREE Newsletter

Footer

Search Our Archive

Search our continually growing archive of over 2500 articles about Workers' Comp issues.

Quiclinks

  • Calculators
  • Terms & Abbreviations
  • Glossary of WC Premium Terms
  • WC Resources
  • Best Practices
  • Industries

RSS Recent Blog Posts

  • Reduce Workers’ Comp Costs in a Union Environment
  • Selecting the Right Service Providers to Reduce Workers’ Comp Costs
  • 3 Techniques To Gain Workers’ Comp Management Commitment
SUBSCRIBE TO OUR FEE NEWSLETTER
Let Us Help You Stomp Down the High Cost of Workers' Comp!
Top of Page ↑
  • Home
  • Training Center
  • Get Started
  • Membership
  • Products
  • Blog
  • About
  • Contact
  • Subscribe
  • Login
Copyright © 2021 Amaxx, LLC. All Rights Reserved. · Privacy Policy / Legal Notice