• Menu
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to secondary navigation
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

Before Header

  • Search
  • About
  • Contact
  • Privacy
 
CHOOSE BROADSPIRE

Amaxx Workers Comp Blog

Reduce Workers Compensation Costs By 20-50%

Header Right

  • Home
    • Training Center
  • Get Started
    • Newcomers Class for WC Professionals
    • Subscribe to Free Newsletter
    • Free Training Center Account
    • Return to Work Resources
    • WC Claims Mgmt. Resources
    • Insurance Advisor Resources
  • Membership
    • Insider (free account)
    • WC Mastery
    • Teams & Managers Mastery
    • Training Partners
  • Products
    • On-Demand Courses
    • Specialty Courses
    • Certifications & Mastery Courses
    • Ultimate Guidebooks
  • Blog
    • Video Blogs
    • COVID-19 / Coronavirus Pandemic
  • Login

Mobile Menu

Choose Broadspire

CHOOSE BROADSPIREBroadspire Delivers Meaningful Results to Our Clients and Their Claimants
  • Home
    • Training Center
  • Get Started
    • Newcomers Class for WC Professionals
    • Subscribe to Free Newsletter
    • Free Training Center Account
    • Return to Work Resources
    • WC Claims Mgmt. Resources
    • Insurance Advisor Resources
  • Membership
    • Insider (free account)
    • WC Mastery
    • Teams & Managers Mastery
    • Training Partners
  • Products
    • On-Demand Courses
    • Specialty Courses
    • Certifications & Mastery Courses
    • Ultimate Guidebooks
  • Blog
    • Video Blogs
    • COVID-19 / Coronavirus Pandemic
  • Login
  • Search
  • About
  • Contact
  • Privacy
You are here: Home / NY Workers Comp Issues / Apportionment and New York Workers Compensation Claims

Apportionment and New York Workers Compensation Claims

January 12, 2011 By //  by Attorney Theodore Ronca Leave a Comment

  1. The GENERAL rule is that you don’t apportion a New York  comp claim with prior injuries. (It is the “You take them as you find them” Rule.)
  1. The “general rule”, however, has quite a few exceptions.
  1. First exception: A prior condition or accident which has progressively worsened and is causing all or part of the reduced earning after an accident may be apportioned. Example: degenerative joint conditions.
  1. Second exception: Prior New York  comp claims. Two, or more, NY comp claims may be apportioned. What about a NY comp claim and an out of state comp claim? Amazingly, although this must occur thousands of time every year, there is no case law on it and nothing in the statute.  Best guess: If the out of state claim can be reopened it is just possible that under some circumstances apportionment could be achieved.
    1. Third exception: New accidents or conditions AFTER the accident which cause wage loss. There is much more flexibility than with prior accidents and conditions. Almost anything AFTER the accident which causes wage loss can be apportioned. Again, there are almost no cases on this. Why? The carriers seldom investigate for accidents and illnesses which occur well after a comp claim, although it is wise and advisable to do so.
      Click Link to Access Free PDF Download

      “The 5Cs to Taking a Bulletproof Injured Worker Recorded Statement”

  1. Fourth exception: Second Injury Fund. It is not generally known that all WCL 15-8(d) (second-injury fund) is an apportionment. When the law was first passed in 1943, during WWII, there was, initially, only apportionment. The judge had to decide how much of a disability (wage loss) was due to the prior condition.

That, very quickly, led to an explosion of trials and appeals, placing an impossible burden on the Board (then called the “Industrial Commission”, until 7/1/47).

The solution was a mandatory apportionment on all 15-8(d) by requiring the carrier to pay the first 260 weeks of disability and the Fund paying everything after. (It was very quickly forgotten that the deductible weeks were actually an apportionment.)

That was amended to 104 weeks a few years later and remained so until the end of the 1990s when it again was raised to 260 weeks until new second-injury fund claims were halted on 7/1/07.

In the 1980s, a bizarre twist was added. A comp judge, as unfamiliar with the history of the law as the lawyers appearing before him, began to allow informal apportionment of the claim between the carrier and the Fund, unaware that the deductible weeks were ALREADY the statutory apportionment. The state later put these “apportionments” into the law, thus creating apportioned apportionments!

FREE DOWNLOAD: “The 5Cs to Taking a Bulletproof Injured Worker Recorded Statement “

Conclusion: Although the general rule is that you can’t apportion comp disability, on nearly every serious claim there is at least one opportunity for apportionment. Serious claims are most likely to happen to older workers, who have, statistically, far more unrelated conditions.

With the abolition of second-injury funds claims in NY, the Board will revert to the 1943 model and there will be trials and appeals on all serious claims in efforts to obtain some apportionment.

NOTE TO EMPLOYERS: ALWAYS inform carriers of all known prior and subsequent accidents, claims and conditions!

Author: Attorney Theodore Ronca is a practicing lawyer from Aquebogue, New York. He is a frequent writer and speaker, and has represented employers in the areas of workers’ compensation, Social Security disability, employee disability plans, and subrogation for over 30 years. Attorney Ronca can be reached at 631-722-2100.

FREE TOOLS

WC BOOKS:   http://www.LowerWC.com/workers-comp-books-manuals.php

WORK COMP CALCULATOR:   http://www.LowerWC.com/calculator.php

MODIFIED DUTY CALCULATOR:   http://www.LowerWC.com/transitional-duty-cost-calculator.php

JOIN WC GROUP:  http://www.linkedin.com/groups?homeNewMember=&gid=1922050/
SUBSCRIBE TO:    Workers Comp Resource Center Newsletter

Do not use this information without independent verification. All state laws vary. You should consult with your insurance broker or agent about workers comp issues.

 ©2010 Amaxx Risk Solutions, Inc. All rights reserved under International Copyright Law. If you would like permission to reprint this material, contact Info@ReduceYourWorkersComp.com

FREE DOWNLOAD: “The 5Cs to Taking a Bulletproof Injured Worker Recorded Statement “

Filed Under: NY Workers Comp Issues Tagged With: Apportionment, NY Workers Comp Law & Issues

Related Articles

New York Work Comp Board To Measure Effectiveness of Carriers/TPAs

New York Work Comp Board To Measure Effectiveness of Carriers/TPAs

Medical Treatment Guidelines In NY Open New Role For Employers

Medical Treatment Guidelines In NY Open New Role For Employers

Employers: In New York It Now Pays To Be A Nit-Picker

Employers: In New York It Now Pays To Be A Nit-Picker

Why NY Workers Comp Proceedings Sooooo Slow”

Why NY Workers Comp Proceedings Sooooo Slow”

Stern Warning Issued For Misclassifying Truck Drivers as Independent Contractors

Stern Warning Issued For Misclassifying Truck Drivers as Independent Contractors

Call For Change With NY Work Comp Facing $10 Billion in Death Claims

Call For Change With NY Work Comp Facing $10 Billion in Death Claims

New York State Fund Is Not The Carrier You Want To Owe Money

New York State Fund Is Not The Carrier You Want To Owe Money

3 Reasons New York Workers Comp Assessments Are Through the Roof

3 Reasons New York Workers Comp Assessments Are Through the Roof

New York Makes Strides with New Rules for Changing Hearing Point

New York Makes Strides with New Rules for Changing Hearing Point

Smile, Your Facebook Post Can be Read by Millions

Smile, Your Facebook Post Can be Read by Millions

New York Corporation Makes Hilarious Decision in Payment of Work Comp Premiums

New York Corporation Makes Hilarious Decision in Payment of Work Comp Premiums

Crackdown on Workers Comp Fraud Leads to 18 Arrests

Crackdown on Workers Comp Fraud Leads to 18 Arrests

Free Download

The 5 Cs For Taking A Bulletproof Injured Worker Recorded Statement - FREE Download Click Here Now!

Train to Succeed

BECOME CERTIFIED IN WORKERS’ COMPENSATION

Proven Course Catalog & WC Toolbox Give You The Power To Achieve Lower Costs and Better Injured Worker Outcomes

VISIT WORKERS' COMP TRAINING CENTER

Previous Post: « Canada Takes Holistic Approach to Severely Injured Workers
Next Post: New York Workers Compensation – Are Guidelines Good »

Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Primary Sidebar

FREE DOWNLOAD

The 5 Cs For Taking A Bulletproof Injured Worker Recorded Statement - FREE Download Click Here Now!

Our Sponsors

Broadspire

Workers’ Comp 3rd-Party Administrator
 

Catastrophic Care Management, Complex Care, and Specialty Networks
 

Ametros

Post-Settlement Administration
 

Medcor

Injury Triage, Onsite Clinics

Read Our Award-Winning Blog

Blog Categories

Search Our Archive

Subscribe to Our FREE Newsletter

Footer

Search Our Archive

Search our continually growing archive of over 2500 articles about Workers' Comp issues.

Quiclinks

  • Calculators
  • Terms & Abbreviations
  • Glossary of WC Premium Terms
  • WC Resources
  • Best Practices
  • Industries

RSS Recent Blog Posts

  • Reduce Workers’ Comp Costs in a Union Environment
  • Selecting the Right Service Providers to Reduce Workers’ Comp Costs
  • 3 Techniques To Gain Workers’ Comp Management Commitment
SUBSCRIBE TO OUR FEE NEWSLETTER
Let Us Help You Stomp Down the High Cost of Workers' Comp!
Top of Page ↑
  • Home
  • Training Center
  • Get Started
  • Membership
  • Products
  • Blog
  • About
  • Contact
  • Subscribe
  • Login
Copyright © 2021 Amaxx, LLC. All Rights Reserved. · Privacy Policy / Legal Notice